Garden City Pizza and Pasta

Reviews

• Mark V.

  star star star star star 12 June 2026

  We stopped here for a change for dinner and were excited to hear it will soon be turned in to a Mediterranean place. As frequent visitors from Boston (which has a lot of these) with family in the area, we're excited to have the option.
  
  This will be great for the town, to have another type of food not Mexican, Italian or Fast.
  
  That being said my wife's steak salad from the current menu was great, as was my steak and cheese.
  
  If you're looking for a solid place to get a good portion of food, this is the spot!

• Shannon M.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 12 June 2026

  We arrived at 2:30 after attempting to eat at Kim's Kitchen and they had closed early.
  We were the only customers but based on the reviews we decided to stay. I ordered ice tea, my daughter got water and my husband ordered a beer. My tea was horrible, I couldn't drink it and asked for a water. My husband's beer was skunk..yuck.
  My husband and I shared the steak and cheese sub and it was ok, nothing special, wished I had hot sauce to add some flavor. My daughter ordered the chicken parmigiana and the breading was soggy, and the pasta was gummy.
  The service was slow especially since we were the only customers.
  Would definitely not return.

• Jessica A.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 9 June 2026

  Came into Pino's the other night. We were the only ones there and service was slow. Took about an hour and a half. Pizza was soggy and the crust was hard. Was disappointed with dinner.

• Jules K.

  star star star star star 25 May 2026

  There is a reason this restaurant has so many reviews and high stars - the pizza was fresh, crust was perfect, buttery and crunchy. Delicious home made baklava and my daughter won something from their claw machine! If you are in this area and need somewhere to eat I highly recommend Pino's - the rest of the menu looked amazing too. Wonderful family owned and operated restaurant with fresh and yummy food.

• Kaicey W.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 16 May 2026

  As much as it kills me to change my rating from my initial review, it's necessary after our last experience. I had raved about the pizza and wings from this place to my husband since I first tried it out so the past couple of trips home to visit our family, we tried to get food from here. First time, we attempted to call in an order for pick up during their hours listed on the takeout menu we had... multiple tries, no answer. It was in the summer so we figured, maybe they were closed for vacation. Oh well... next time. Well, once again we tried on our past trip home and even made a point to call first to make sure they were open before driving all the way there. This was a Friday around lunch time. They answered and said yes they were open and we inquired about lunch specials then stated we were on our way. After a probably 30-45 min drive there- all of us starving- we find the place closed! At no point did the lady who answered the call say they would be closing soon and the hours on the door even stated they were open all day. I feel this is no way to conduct business. Either we just have really bad luck and catch them on times when things come up unexpectedly, or they just open and close as they see fit, which I feel will do the business a major disservice in the long run. It's very disappointing because the food really was delicious but I don't see myself making the drive again on the off chance that they may actually be open. Especially after we made a point to call and ask this past time and still wasted the time and gas.